Home › Mail-in repair

Mail-in shoe & boot repair services compared

Last checked: Nov 18, 2026 · Prices, turnaround and shipping terms quoted from each service's own pages.

Quick picks from what's published. Own Allen Edmonds, Red Wing or Danner? The maker's program posts a fixed price ($150, $165 and $100–$140 respectively). Any other brand: NuShoe posts all-in packages from $95 with a provided FedEx label and a 3–6 week wait; Wyatt & Dad and McFarland post premium leather options but Wyatt & Dad's posted lead time was 12 weeks.
ServiceWorks onPosted pricesTurnaround (as published)How shipping worksSource
Allen Edmonds RecraftingAllen Edmonds shoes only$150 Standard / $175 Prestige; heels only $50“About 4–6 weeks” from receiptBuy online; continental-US customers get a prepaid label, or drop at an AE storesource
Red Wing Repair ShopWelted Red Wing, WORX and Irish Setter boots$165 resole; $180 Premium Repair Package; $60 heels onlyNot publishedPrint repair form; free shipping label from customer service for services over $50, or bring to a Red Wing storesource
Danner RecraftingDanner boots (uppers free of holes and major cracking)$100–$140 resole; $280 rebuild4 weeks from receiptFree shipping back to yousource
NuShoeAny brand; authorized program for several brandsExecutive NuCraft $95; Chairman NuCraft $125; Outdoorsman NuCraft $95“3 – 6 weeks”Mail shoes with provided FedEx labelsource
Fred's Shoe Repair (Peoria, IL)Any brand; authorized Birkenstock repair centerLeather resole package $165–$335; Birkenstock $70–$120; belt shortening $20Birkenstock: approx. 2–4 weeks after arrivalOrder online, ship to 3033 N. University St., Peoria, IL 61604source
Wyatt & Dad Cobbler Co. (Winston-Salem, NC)Any brand; Goodyear welted most commonStandard leather full soles & heels $185–$390 depending on leather, heel and welts“Current lead time: 12 weeks” (homepage)Order online; cobbler consultation on arrival; stitchdown boots may cost moresource
McFarland Shoe Repair (Lakeland, FL)Any brandLeather full soles & rubber heels $195–$370; Birkenstock $80–$145Not captured on pages checkedOrder/quote online; shop at 5355 South Florida Ave, Lakeland FL 33813source
Tulsa Shoe Rebuilders (Tulsa, OK)Any brand (lists 150+ brands)Men's full leather sole $75 & up; Birkenstock re-sole $70 & up (shipping extra)Not captured on pages checkedShoe Repair by Mail instructions; postage-paid bag or box available on requestsource
B. Nelson Shoes (New York, NY)High-grade dress shoes; also Birkenstock and cowboy bootsPackages on its order page (not captured)“Allow 10 to 14 days for return delivery”Printable mailing label on sitesource
Leather Spa (New York, NY)Shoes, boots, bags, beltsNot published on pages checkedNot published on pages checkedMail-in service; drop-off at The UPS Storesource

Before you ship

  • Check eligibility: brand programs only work on their own brand, and Allen Edmonds and Red Wing both say prior work by other repair shops may prevent them from repairing a pair.
  • Remove laces, insoles and shoe trees you want back – Allen Edmonds says it can't return them.
  • Ask about up-charges for stitchdown construction or extra damage (Wyatt & Dad does a consultation after arrival).

See all posted prices in the resole cost guide.

Not listed: Unsung House (Nashville) is often recommended by owners on Reddit, but its website did not load when we checked on Nov 18, 2026, so we couldn't verify prices or terms.